Skip to content
Donnelly + Co.
A Better Approach to Real Estate
- Story
- Properties
- Boston
- Martha’s vineyard
- Sales
- Vacation Rentals
- People
- Blog
- Contact
- Story
- Properties
- Boston
- Martha’s vineyard
- Sales
- Vacation Rentals
- People
- Blog
- Contact
Martha's Vineyard Real Estate
Just 7 miles off the coast of Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard is a New England treasure. Breathtakingly lovely, temperate and unspoiled, with a vibrant arts scene, fantastic local food and easy transportation (via ferry or air), Martha’s Vineyard real estate is highly sought-after—with prices that can run from steep to head-spinning.
The Martha’s Vineyard Real Estate Market
The Island has accommodated European settlers since the 1600s (as well as the indigenous Wampanoag people before them). Yet, unlike some other seaside locales, Martha’s Vineyard has retained much of its natural beauty.
About 30% of its 57,000 acres are permanently protected from development, and its residents are keeping the environment pristine. No chain hotels, restaurants or stores mar the scenery here. Instead you’ll find miles of hiking and biking trails, white beaches, freshwater ponds, fresh air and ocean breezes.
On the Island, six towns comprise most of the real estate on offer, from modern condos to clapboard saltboxes to classic Victorians and great seaside estates. So ask yourself: what speaks to you?
Contact Us Today for a Free Consultation
Martha's Vineyard Properties For Sale
2 East Side Road
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $2,575,000
3 / 2 Full Baths
1,594 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
29 Llewellyn Way
Edgartown
List Price: $4,850,000
5 / 4 Full Baths / 2 Half Baths
5,195 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
5 Farm Path
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $1,725,000
4 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
1,920 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
43C Dark Woods Road
Edgartown
List Price: $2,495,000
4 / 3 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
2,695 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
67 Hidden Village
West Tisbury
List Price: $3,795,000
7 / 5 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
4,476 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
19 Oakdale Drive
Edgartown
List Price: $1,575,000
2 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
1,436 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
68 Shawanue Ave
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $990,000
3 / 1 Full Bath
1,104 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
7 Allen Street
Edgartown
List Price: $2,250,000
4 / 3 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
2,310 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
496 Lamberts Cove Road
West Tisbury
List Price: $1,225,000
2 / 1 Full Bath
1,286 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
62 Lagoon Pond Road A
Tisbury
List Price: $975,000
3 / 1 Full Bath
920 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
62 Lagoon Pond Road B
Tisbury
List Price: $1,475,000
3 / 2 Full Baths
1,682 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
267 Barnes Road
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $5,850,000
3 / 5 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
4,046 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
53 Road To The Plains
Edgartown
List Price: $4,850,000
5 / 4 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
3,892 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
10 Gert's Way
Edgartown
List Price: $2,450,000
4 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
2,404 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
40 Waldrons Bottom Road
West Tisbury
List Price: $3,500,000
6 / 4 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
4,054 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
77 Cooke St
Edgartown
List Price: $5,900,000
5 / 5 Full Baths / 2 Half Baths
3,607 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
137 Charles Neck Way
West Tisbury
List Price: $1,910,000
5 / 4 Full Baths
2,610 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
00 Kennebago
Tisbury
List Price: $925,000
0 /
0 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
18 Woodhaven Dr
Edgartown
List Price: $3,200,000
3 / 3 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
3,481 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
The Martha’s Vineyard Lifestyle
Martha’s Vineyard can be a quiet retreat, a celebrity hangout, an athlete’s mecca, an art lover’s dream—or a little bit of each. You just need to know where to look.
Edgartown, former whaling port, buzzes as a tourist destination and focal point for Victorian-era home renovation. Oak Bluffs, famed for its vintage “gingerbread” cottages, is a summer port of entry and a magnet for Island nightlife. Vineyard Haven is the main port for Martha’s Vineyard, overseeing a range of eating and entertainment spots.
On the quieter side, West Tisbury is the Island’s agricultural center; here you’ll find Long Point Wildlife Refuge just east of Tisbury Great Pond. Rural Chilmark is home to the quaint fishing village of Menemsha, plus beaches and wild sanctuaries. And far to the west, Aquinnah, historic home of the Wampanoag people, remains a place of deep beauty and serenity.
So many options. The only question now: where’s your perfect place on Martha’s Vineyard?
Is Now A Good Time To Buy On Martha’s Vineyard?
The answer to that depends on your lifestyle—and pocketbook. It’s important to recognize that the cost of living on the Island can be as much as 60% higher than the national average, with housing prices up to 96% percent higher. Paradise can be pricey. Having said that, no one can put a price tag on living the dream. If Martha’s Vineyard is yours—for part or all of the year—go for it. You’ll find yourself in very good company.
Looking for vacation rentals? Browse our Martha’s Vineyard rental properties today.
10 Gert's Way
Edgartown
List Price: $2,450,000
4 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
2,404 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
64 Jernegan Pond Rd
Edgartown
List Price: $1,385,000
1 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
1,637 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
28 Vickers Street
Edgartown
List Price: $2,050,000
3 / 2 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
1,862 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
28 Woodhaven Dr
Edgartown
List Price: $2,475,000
3 / 3 Full Baths / 1 Half Bath
3,470 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
32 South Pond Road
West Tisbury
List Price: $3,100,000
3 / 3 Full Baths
2,670 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
201 Spring St
Tisbury
List Price: $1,275,000
4 / 2 Full Baths
2,080 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
57 Vineyard Meadow Farms Rd
West Tisbury
List Price: $990,000
3 / 2 Full Baths
1,450 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
389 Barnes Road
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $2,400,000
3 / 1 Full Bath
936 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
39 Prices Way
Edgartown
List Price: $1,399,000
4 / 2 Full Baths
1,532 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
131 North Water 51
Edgartown
List Price: $1,995,000
1 / 1 Full Bath
862 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
459 State Road 20
Tisbury
List Price: $975,000
0 /
0 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
9 Wendall Avenue
Oak Bluffs
List Price: $850,000
2 / 1 Full Bath
1,040 sqft SqFt
Contact Listing Agent
Megan Laikin
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“People let me into their lives at an important time, and I don’t take that for granted.”
View details
Jennifer McDougall
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“The question is, what do our clients want, and more importantly, how do we make it easier and more fun?”
View details
Julia Smith
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“It always ends with joy.”
View details
Carol Shore
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“You never know what the day will bring. And that’s exciting.”
View details
Stephanie W. Roache
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“It’s a privilege to help my clients achieve their Island dreams, just like I did.”
View details
Jim Osmundsen
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“I just work with my clients honestly.”
View details
Stacy Ickes
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“I enjoy putting the pieces together to find the right match.”
View details
Terie Geary
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“It’s important to work with a common goal in mind and get over the hurdles together.”
View details
Allison Fisher Snowden
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“It never feels like a job.”
View details
Katrina Lima
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“It’s not about buying or selling it’s about building memories.”
View details
Katie Dawson
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“Jump and the net will appear.”
View details
Shelley Christiansen
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“The devil is in the details. I’ve got the devil by the tail.”
View details
Kristin Buck
Sales Agent - Martha's Vineyard
“Always prepare for what could be around the corner.”
View details